TRALAC - Trade Law Centre

Lobbyist says US likely to punish East Africa over mitumba ban

Saturday, 26 August 2017

Source: Daily Nation (Kenya)

Donald Trump administration trade officials are likely to rule that three East African countries are violating eligibility terms for the US preferential trade programme for Africa, a lobbyist for Kenya warned on Friday.

“The stars are aligned” for such a ruling before the end of the year, said Washington based attorney Paul Ryberg, an expert on the Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa).

Mr Ryberg has been retained by both the Kenya Ministry of Industry, Trade and Cooperation and the Kenya Association of Manufacturers to lobby on Agoa-related matters.

At issue is a US government trade agency’s earlier-than-scheduled assessment of Agoa compliance in Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda.

AGOA

The agency’s move to conduct this “out-of-cycle review” of their Agoa status came in response to a US business association’s petition in March urging that the three countries be barred from exporting clothing to the US under Agoa’s duty-free provisions.

The Secondary Materials and Recycled Textiles Association, known as Smart, argued at a public hearing in Washington in July that the cut-off of mitumba imports from the US runs counter to Agoa’s prohibition against “barriers to US trade.”

Officials from Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda testified at the same hearing that their agreed-upon three-year phase-out of mitumba imports is a necessary tool for nurturing their own garment-producing industries.

The three targeted countries also contended that the mitumba ban does not contradict Agoa’s eligibility criteria.

PETITION

Mr Ryberg maintains that the US trade agency’s acceptance of Smart’s petition was based on an “erroneous” finding.

He said the mitumba ban does not violate Agoa standards because the clothing at issue was manufactured outside the United States and thus does not qualify as a “US export.” Nearly all the clothing sold in the US are made in other countries, Mr Ryberg noted.

He acknowledged however that “Smart was very smart — if you’ll excuse the pun — to move for an out-of-cycle review at this time because the Trump administration wants to show they’re tough on trade. And such a demonstration is easy to make in the case of “three poor countries that can’t fight back,” Mr Ryberg added.

Smart initially wanted Kenya included in the trade agency’s out-of-cycle review — a step that could have led to the loss of tens of thousands of Agoa-dependent jobs in Kenya.

IMPORTS

But US trade officials decided to exclude Kenya from the review on the grounds that the Nairobi government had reversed its move to join in a coordinated mitumba import ban by East African Community member-states.

Mr Ryberg said a new study by the US Agency for International Development (USAid) as signaling the likelihood of Trump administration punitive action against Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda.

USAid’s East Africa Trade and Investment Hub concluded in a 30-page analysis issued last week that a ban on mitumba imports is not needed to bolster domestic clothing manufacturing in Africa.

“EAC policy makers would be well advised to keep both used clothing sector and AGOA export benefits while focusing on domestic industry development, knowing these are not mutually exclusive goals,” the USAid trade hub study concluded.

USAid estimates that the used clothing industry accounts for 355,000 jobs in the EAC countries, which in turn generate $230 million in income that supports some 1.4 million East Africans.

TEXTILES

The mitumba ban could meanwhile jeopardise another 219,000 jobs in East Africa related to Agoa, the study calculated. It noted that the EAC countries last year exported $435 million in goods to the US under Agoa, with clothing accounting for 88 per cent of the sum.

Tanzania would suffer significantly from loss of Agoa benefits because it has a small but significant clothing manufacturing sector, Mr Ryberg said.

“Uganda is trying to build its industry, and there has been some growth,” he added. “The sad thing is, this (the loss of Agoa eligibility) will nip it in the bud.”

Kenya is by far the largest Agoa beneficiary in East Africa and this standing motivated Nairobi’s decision to withdraw from the mitumba phase-out agreement.

Kenya companies registered $394 million in textile and apparel sales to US buyers last year.

Kenya is so eager to protect its Agoa-related revenues and jobs that it has retained not only Mr Ryberg’s firm but another Washington lobbying group to help ensure that it retains duty-free access to the US market.

TOURISM

The Sonoran Policy Group, which includes executives with previous ties to the Trump administration, has been retained at a rate of $100,000 per month for a period of at least three months to lobby on Kenya’s behalf in regard to Agoa and to promote tourism.

The law firm of Ryberg and Smith, LLC was recently hired primarily to lobby against Kenya’s inclusion in the out-of-cycle Agoa status review.

Disclosure forms filed at the US Justice Department show that Mr Ryberg’s firm is being paid a base retainer fee of $10,000.

The agreement with the Kenya Ministry of Industry, Trade and Cooperation calls for payment of an additional $25,000 for services that the firm would provide if US trade officials were to include Kenya in the out-of-cycle Agoa eligibility review.

Officials at the Kenya embassy in Washington did not respond to requests for comment on the lobbying agreement with Mr Ryberg’s firm.

 

View related news articles

Uganda's Museveni to investors: Exploit Africa’s untapped investment potential

Uganda's Museveni to investors: Exploit Africa’s untapped investment potential

Uganda's President Yoweri Museveni has told a group of African-American investors who are in the country to explore investment opportunities that investing in Uganda is a ‘sure deal’ to the success of their projects because of the prevailing excellent investment environment in the country. The 16 member team was led by Senegalese-American celebrity and businessman...

18 May, 2021
'The opportunities are vast in a potential US-Kenya FTA'

'The opportunities are vast in a potential US-Kenya FTA'

Last year, the U.S. and Kenya announced the launch of free trade negotiations, the first of its kind between the U.S. and a sub-Saharan Africa country. If successful, it would be the most significant trade development in the region since the enactment of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) trade preference program in 2000. To better understand the key issues...

06 May, 2021
Report: A look at the potential benefits and challenges of a US – Kenya trade agreement

Report: A look at the potential benefits and challenges of a US – Kenya trade agreement

The American Chamber of Commerce (AmCham) Kenya has partnered with the U.S. Africa Business Centre (USAfBC) and Covington to publish a business trade report. The report, titled US-Kenya Trade Negotiations: Implications for the Future of the U.S.-Africa Trade Relationship, examines the challenges and benefits of a potential free trade agreement (FTA) between the...

30 April, 2021
Kenya: 'Uhuru–Blinken talks a breath of life to US trade deal'

Kenya: 'Uhuru–Blinken talks a breath of life to US trade deal'

Trade talks between Kenya and the US could resume soon following Tuesday's virtual meeting between President Uhuru Kenyatta and US Secretary of State Antony Blinken. This is after a five-month break occasioned by change of g-uard in the US as President Joe Biden took over from Donald Trump after last November’s elections. The settling down of the Biden administration put...

29 April, 2021
'Biden Administration dampens Kenya's hopes for bilateral trade deal'

'Biden Administration dampens Kenya's hopes for bilateral trade deal'

The Biden administration's plans to review foreign trade policy and refocus it on America's economic recovery have thrown long-running free trade negotiations with Kenya into disarray. In a development that casts doubts on the future of a bilateral free trade agreement (FTA) with Kenya, United States Trade Representative Katherine Tai has informed Kenyan Minister...

05 April, 2021
Rwanda eyes stronger ties with Biden Administration

Rwanda eyes stronger ties with Biden Administration

The Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, Vincent Biruta, has said that Rwanda is ready to strengthen ties with the administration of the new President of the United States, Joe Biden. Biden was sworn-in on January 20, becoming the 46th President of the US. "We are ready to continue working with the new administration in strengthening existing...

25 January, 2021
'Uncertainty around Kenya-US Free trade deal'

'Uncertainty around Kenya-US Free trade deal'

A cloud of uncertainty has engulfed Kenya’s pursuit of a free trade agreement (FTA) with the United States due to the impending change of guard at the White House.  Even before he takes office, President-elect Joe Biden has sent strong indications of plans to annul many of President Donald Trump’s policies, cutting across trade, environment and geopolitics...

18 January, 2021
Kenya exports to US climb to Sh67 billion

Kenya exports to US climb to Sh67 billion

Kenyan exports to America under the Africa Growth Opportunities Act (AGOA) hit Sh67 billion last year, a marginal increase of 3.7 per cent from Sh64 billion recorded in the previous year. According to the latest report from the Office of the US Trade Representative, Kenya emerged the fourth exporter under Agoa, after Nigeria (Sh310 billion), South Africa (Sh200 billion) and...

30 December, 2020
Uganda to work on increasing exports in wake of Covid-19 challenges

Uganda to work on increasing exports in wake of Covid-19 challenges

In the wake of COVID-19 and its devastating effects, Uganda is producing solution-based products onto market. Unlike in the past, Ugandan products have been warmly received by local consumers because of their improved quality, says NRM National Treasurer Namayanja Rose Nsereko. According to her, Ugandan scientists are in final stages of testing COVID-19 vaccines with 90%...

13 December, 2020
Opinion: 'Kenya-US relations really do matter'

Opinion: 'Kenya-US relations really do matter'

With the shadow of the bitterly contested American presidential elections looming over us, the past few weeks have seen much discussion on the relationship between Kenya and the US. The average American may not care much who gets to be the president of Kenya – indeed would generally have no idea of it, if there was a presidential election taking place in Kenya. But most...

05 November, 2020
'From AGOA to FTA - Kenya-US ties growing from strength to strength'

'From AGOA to FTA - Kenya-US ties growing from strength to strength'

[Opinion] The 56-year-old United States-Kenya relationship flourishes because we trust each other, respect each other and our nations share common values. Both believe in a strong economy through an open, free marketplace allowing entrepreneurs, businesses and the private sector to thrive and create jobs. The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) enhanced markets,...

29 October, 2020